| 1967 | 2-6 | 1972 | 3-5-1 | St. Francis | W, 14-0 | ||
| Maumee | W, 24-12 | Central | L, 0-13 | Waite | W, 21-0 | ||
| Orrville | L, 0-6 | Woodward | L, 6-12 | Rogers | W, 41-0 | ||
| Taylor Center | W, 12-6 | Cardinal Stritch | L, 6-34 | Bowsher | W, 42-0 | ||
| Tiffin Calvert | L, 16-22 | Rogers | T, 0-0 | Cardinal Stritch | L, 0-3 | ||
| Scott | L, 0-35 | Sylvania | W, 12-0 | City Championship | |||
| Monroe Central Catholic | L, 13-33 | St. Francis | L, 14-42 | Central | W, 18-6 | ||
| Springfield | L, 12-26 | Waite | W, 8-6 | ||||
| Bowsher | L, 2-8 | Bowsher | L, 0-7 | 1977 | 9-2 | ||
| Libbey | W, 27-6 | Central | L, 14-24 | ||||
| 1968 | 5-4 | Start | W, 14-7 | ||||
| Central | L, 0-3 | 1973 | 6-4 | Macomber | W, 48-0 | ||
| Woodward | W, 14-6 | Central | L, 7-14 | Libbey | W, 10-6 | ||
| Cardinal Stritch | W, 6-0 | Woodward | L, 6-16 | Whitmer | W, 3-0 | ||
| Rogers | L, 12-26 | Cardinal Stritch | W, 15-10 | St. Francis | L, 12-21 | ||
| Waite | W, 13-6 | Rogers | W, 12-0 | Anthony Wayne | W, 19-0 | ||
| Sandusky Perkins | L, 0-6 | Sylvania | W, 6-0 | Rogers | W, 36-0 | ||
| Libbey | W, 14-0 | St. Francis | W, 7-0 | Clay | W, 35-14 | ||
| Start | W, 14-6 | Waite | L, 16-20 | Cardinal Stritch | W, 35-0 | ||
| St. Francis | L, 0-27 | Bowsher | W, 14-6 | City Championship | |||
| Libbey | W, 35-14 | St. Francis | W, 21-13 | ||||
| 1969 | 6-3 | City Championship | |||||
| Central | L, 0-20 | DeVilbiss | L, 0-7 | 1978 | 6-4 | ||
| Woodward | W, 14-12 | Central | W, 20-0 | ||||
| Cardinal Stritch | L, 12-14 | 1974 | 7-3 | Maumee | L, 0-21 | ||
| Rogers | W, 20-6 | Central | L, 0-7 | Fremont Ross | L, 8-27 | ||
| Waite | W, 18-8 | Woodward | W, 25-20 | Libbey | W, 34-0 | ||
| Sandusky Perkins | W, 35-6 | Cardinal Stritch | W, 23-12 | Whitmer | W, 7-6 | ||
| Libbey | W, 33-26 | Rogers | W, 32-0 | St. Francis | W, 20-7 | ||
| Start | W, 20-8 | Sylvania | L, 6-14 | Waite | W, 35-8 | ||
| St. Francis | L, 0-6 | St. Francis | W, 7-6 | Rogers | W, 27-0 | ||
| Waite | W, 29-12 | Bowsher | L, 16-23 | ||||
| 1970 | 7-2 | Bowsher | W, 14-8 | Cardinal Stritch | L, 0-32 | ||
| Central | W, 18-7 | Libbey | W, 21-0 | ||||
| Woodward | W, 20-12 | City Championship | 1979 | 4-6 | |||
| Cardinal Stritch | W, 38-7 | DeVilbiss | L, 20-42 | Central | L, 7-10 | ||
| Rogers | L, 7-18 | Maumee | L, 0-7 | ||||
| Waite | W, 35-6 | 1975 | 7-2-1 | Traverse City | W, 7-6 | ||
| Libbey | W, 15-0 | Central | W, 7-0 | Libbey | W, 24-6 | ||
| Start | W, 13-0 | Start | W, 14-6 | Whitmer | L, 0-18 | ||
| St. Francis | W, 6-0 | Libbey | W, 15-14 | St. Francis | L, 7-28 | ||
| City Championship | Whitmer | L, 7-20 | Waite | W, 7-0 | |||
| Macomber | L, 3-14 | St. Francis | W, 7-0 | Rogers | W, 7-6 | ||
| Rogers | W, 20-3 | Bowsher | L, 7-24 | ||||
| 1971 | 3-5-1 | Waite | W, 43-6 | Cardinal Stritch | L, 6-14 | ||
| Central | L, 6-14 | Bowsher | W, 22-0 | ||||
| Woodward | L, 0-16 | Cardinal Stritch | L, 14-15 | 1980 | 7-4 | ||
| Cardinal Stritch | L, 0-26 | City Championship | Sandusky | L, 6-24 | |||
| Rogers | W, 14-0 | Woodward | T, 7-7 | Central | W, 17-14 | ||
| Sylvania | T, 0-0 | Maumee | W, 17-14 | ||||
| Waite | L, 0-6 | 1976 | 8-2 | Cardinal Stritch | L, 9-19 | ||
| Libbey | W, 34-16 | Central | W, 20-12 | Libbey | W, 13-8 | ||
| Start | W, 0-13 | Start | L, 7-9 | Whitmer | L, 0-20 | ||
| St. Francis | L, 0-21 | Libbey | W, 21-0 | St. Francis | W, 10-7 | ||
| Whitmer | W, 19-0 | ||||||
| 1980 (Continued) | St. Francis | L, 8-21 | 1989 | 5-5 | |||
| Waite | W, 35-6 | Waite | W, 41-27 | Strongsville | L, 14-20 | ||
| Rogers | W, 14-7 | Rogers | T, 14-14 | Central | L, 7-21 | ||
| Bowsher | W, 9-7 | Bowsher | W, 14-13 | Bowsher | W, 27-8 | ||
| City Championship | Waite | W, 21-0 | |||||
| Macomber | L, 0-15 | 1985 | 8-3 | Northview | L, 0-7 | ||
| Sandusky | W, 3-0 | Walsh Jesuit | L, 0-28 | ||||
| 1981 | 9-2 | Central | L, 6-14 | St. Francis | W, 13-10 OT | ||
| Sandusky | L | Maumee | W, 32-13 | Waite | W, 27-0 | ||
| Central | W | Cardinal Stritch | W, 28-7 | Rogers | W, 48-8 | ||
| Maumee | W | Libbey | W, 14-0 | City Championship | |||
| Cardinal Stritch | W | Woodward | W, 7-0 | DeVilbiss | L, 13-17 | ||
| Libbey | W | St. Francis | W, 10-9 | ||||
| Whitmer | L | Waite | L, 7-14 | 1990 | 9-2 | ||
| St. Francis | W | Rogers | W, 21-20 | Maumee | W, 23-13 | ||
| Waite | W | Bowsher | W, 35-28 | Central | W, 12-6 | ||
| Rogers | W | City Championship | Bowsher | W, 33-0 | |||
| Bowsher | W | Scott | L, 42-0 | Macomber | W, 17-6 | ||
| City Championship | Northview | W, 45-0 | |||||
| Macomber | W | 1986 | 4-5 | Walsh Jesuit | W, 21-7 | ||
| Sandusky | L, 8-14 | St. Francis | W, 7-3 | ||||
| 1982 | 7-3-1 | Central | L, 6-9 | Warren Harding | L, 3-15 | ||
| Sandusky | L, 7-13 | Bowsher | W, 39-21 | Rogers | W, 43-0 | ||
| Central | T, 7-7 | Cardinal Stritch | W, 41-7 | City Championship | |||
| Maumee | W, 26-12 | Libbey | W, 30-0 | Macomber | W, 6-0 | ||
| Cardinal Stritch | W, 38-6 | Woodward | W, 21-0 | State Playoffs | |||
| Libbey | W, 36-0 | St. Francis | L, 7-12 | Sandusky | L, 15-21 | ||
| Whitmer | L, 14-23 | Waite | L, 9-13 | ||||
| St. Francis | W, 17-7 | Rogers | L, 0-6 | 1991 | 8-3 | ||
| Waite | W, 27-0 | Maumee | W, 33-6 | ||||
| Rogers | W, 26-20 | 1987 | 7-3 | Fremont Ross | W, 21-7 | ||
| Bowsher | W, 16-14 | Sandusky | L, 9-20 | Findlay | W, 26-7 | ||
| City Championship | Central | L, 17-19 | Elyria | W, 21-14 | |||
| Central | L, 7-21 | Bowsher | W, 14-0 | Woodward | W, 35-14 | ||
| Cardinal Stritch | W, 36-0 | Walsh Jesuit | L, 13-15 | ||||
| 1983 | 5-5 | Cle. John Adams | W, 23-16 | Central | W, 41-21 | ||
| Sandusky | L, 0-28 | Cle. St. Edward's | L, 21-41 | St. Francis | W, 28-14 | ||
| Central | L, 0-14 | St. Francis | W, 14-0 | Uniontown Lake | L, 7-14 | ||
| Maumee | W, 13-6 | Waite | W, 23-13 | State Playoffs | |||
| Cardinal Stritch | L, 0-20 | Rogers | W, 7-6 | Barberton | W, 10-7 | ||
| Libbey | W, 28-7 | City Championship | Massillon | L, 21-42 | |||
| Whitmer | L, 0-40 | Central | W, 33-21 | ||||
| St. Francis | L, 0-27 | 1992 | 8-3 | ||||
| Waite | W, 10-0 | 1988 | 7-2 | Det. Cath. Central | L, 0-36 | ||
| Rogers | W, 14-6 | Sandusky | L, 10-20 | Fremont Ross | L, 6-26 | ||
| Bowsher | W, 9-0 | Central | W, 7-0 | Findlay | W, 20-13 | ||
| Bowsher | W, 20-6 | Bryan | W, 21-9 | ||||
| 1984 | 3-6-1 | Cardinal Stritch | W, 27-7 | St. Francis | L, 0-21 | ||
| Sandusky | L, 6-14 | Walsh Jesuit | W, 16-7 | Scott | W, 18-8 | ||
| Central | L, 0-21 | Lumen Christi | W, 28-7 | Rogers | W, 35-14 | ||
| Maumee | L, 0-7 | St. Francis | L, 6-14 | Bowsher | W, 35-18 | ||
| Cardinal Stritch | W, 7-0 | Waite | W, 24-7 | Waite | W, 28-15 | ||
| Libbey | L, 0-13 | Rogers | W, 39-12 | Central | W, 28-13 | ||
| Whitmer | L, 0-47 | Hall of Fame Bowl | |||||
| Start | W, 20-8 | ||||||
| 1993 | 5-5 | 1997 | 8-3 | 2001 | 6-5 | ||
| Fostoria | L, 7-39 | Columbus DeSales | W, 10-0 | Cle. St. Ignatius | L, 7-42 | ||
| Fremont Ross | L, 20-35 | Cincinnati Elder | L, 15-18 | University of Detroit High | L, 19-21 | ||
| Findlay | L, 7-14 | Fostoria | W, 20-14 | Grove City | L, 0-32 | ||
| Bryan | W, 20-7 | Adrian | W, 41-7 | Lima Senior | W, 24-7 | ||
| St. Francis | L, 7-35 | Central | W, 40-0 | Start | W, 17-7 | ||
| Scott | W, 35-0 | Bowsher | W, 44-13 | Central | L, 10-14 | ||
| Rogers | L, 10-17 | Start | W, 6-0 | Rogers | W, 28-0 | ||
| Bowsher | W, 45-17 | Scott | W, 38-18 | St. Francis | L, 7-28 | ||
| Waite | W, 38-12 | Rogers | W, 42-13 | Scott | W, 22-14 | ||
| Central | W, 10-7 | St. Francis | L, 22-28 | Waite | W, 39-14 | ||
| Hall of Fame Bowl | Hall of Fame Bowl | ||||||
| 1994 | 8-3 | Start | L, 7-17 | Scott | W, 31-6 | ||
| Fostoria | W, 17-8 | ||||||
| Fremont Ross | L, 13-38 | 1998 | 6-5 | 2002 | 7-4 | ||
| Findlay | W, 7-6 | Columbus DeSales | L, 8-22 | Findlay | L, 7-30 | ||
| Cle. St. Ignatius | L, 6-38 | Bir. Brother Rice | L, 13-14 | University of Detroit High | W, 6-0 | ||
| Central | W, 24-20 | Fostoria | W, 22-8 | Grove City | W, 7-6 | ||
| Scott | W, 52-0 | Cle. St. Ignatius | L, 10-14 | Lima Senior | W, 23-8 | ||
| Woodward | W, 42-7 | Start | W, 17-7 | Central | L, 24-35 | ||
| St. Francis | W, 33-12 | Central | W, 21-13 | Rogers | W, 21-0 | ||
| Rogers | W, 44-8 | Scott | W, 37-6 | St. Francis | L, 3-27 | ||
| Start | W, 37-12 | St. Francis | L, 9-10 | Scott | W, 27-7 | ||
| State Playoffs | Waite | W, 20-14 | Start | W, 20-13 | |||
| Canton McKinley | L, 14-17 | Rogers | W, 42-8 | Woodward | W, 42-6 | ||
| Hall of Fame Bowl | State Playoffs | ||||||
| 1995 | 8-3 | St. Francis | L, 7-41 | Springfield South | L, 17-32 | ||
| Warren De La Salle | W, 15-8 | ||||||
| University of Detroit High | W, 49-7 | 1999 | 8-3 | 2003 | 10-4 | ||
| Indianapolis Cathedral | W, 42-8 | Columbus DeSales | L, 18-26 | Findlay | L, 7-42 | ||
| Cle. St. Ignatius | L, 29-33 | Fremont Ross | W, 33-0 | Columbus DeSales | L, 14-20 OT | ||
| Central | W, 42-0 | Fostoria | W, 47-0 | University of Detroit High | W, 35-34 OT | ||
| Waite | W, 49-12 | Cle. St. Ignatius | L, 17-24 | Central | W, 21-20 | ||
| Rogers | W, 31-6 | St. Francis | L, 20-26 | Start | W, 23-7 | ||
| Bowsher | W, 39-24 | Libbey | W, 38-6 | St. Francis | L, 6-7 | ||
| Start | W, 42-14 | Central | W, 10-7 | Rogers | W, 43-6 | ||
| St. Francis | L, 17-21 | Scott | W, 33-14 | Scott | W, 35-6 | ||
| State Playoffs | Bowsher | W, 43-14 | Waite | W, 54-7 | |||
| Brunswick | L, 21-31 | Start | W, 14-6 | Whitmer | W, 34-27 | ||
| Hall of Fame Bowl | State Playoffs | ||||||
| 1996 | 9-2 | Bowsher | W, 43-7 | Whitmer | W, 28-14 | ||
| Columbus DeSales | W, 14-10 | Brunswick | W, 9-7 | ||||
| Cincinnati Elder | W, 16-14 | 2000 | 5-6 | Wadsworth | W, 15-12 | ||
| Fostoria | W, 29-8 | Cle. St. Ignatius | L, 14-48 | Cle. St. Edward's | L, 7-44 | ||
| Indianapolis Cathedral | L, 14-28 | Fremont Ross | L, 0-41 | ||||
| Bowsher | W, 20-14 | Tiffin Columbian | L, 7-14 | 2004 | 7-4 | ||
| Start | W, 38-13 | Lima Senior | L, 10-14 | Findlay | W, 31-7 | ||
| Rogers | W, 21-7 | Start | W, 27-7 | Columbus DeSales | L, 10-21 | ||
| Central | W, 21-7 | Waite | W, 22-0 | Col. Bishop Watterson | L, 5-14 | ||
| Scott | W, 43-18 | Libbey | W, 39-0 | Central | W, 13-10 | ||
| St. Francis | W, 24-21 | Rogers | L, 0-22 | Start | W, 30-21 | ||
| State Playoffs | Bowsher | W, 56-14 | St. Francis | L, 7-14 | |||
| Lima Senior | L, 14-28 | St. Francis | W, 14-7 | Rogers | W, 59-0 | ||
| Hall of Fame Bowl | Scott | W, 41-6 | |||||
| Central | L, 28-7 | Waite | W, 40-0 | ||||
| 2004 (Continued) | |||||||
| Whitmer | L, 7-8 | ||||||
| Hall of Fame Bowl | |||||||
| Bowsher | W, 35-12 | ||||||
| 2005 | 8-3 | ||||||
| Findlay | W, 42-38 | ||||||
| Columbus DeSales | W, 20-17 | ||||||
| Woodward | W, 48-0 | ||||||
| Clay | W, 28-0 | ||||||
| Scott | W, 21-14 | ||||||
| Waite | W, 56-13 | ||||||
| Start | W, 29-12 | ||||||
| Whitmer | W, 38-6 | ||||||
| St. Francis | L, 13-17 | ||||||
| Central | L, 21-27 | ||||||
| State Playoffs | |||||||
| Elyria | L, 9-21 | ||||||
| 2006 | 8-3 | ||||||
| Findlay | W, 24-16 | ||||||
| Columbus DeSales | L, 10-34 | ||||||
| Woodward | W, 46-0 | ||||||
| Clay | W, 35-7 | ||||||
| Scott | W, 31-12 | ||||||
| Waite | W, 52-0 | ||||||
| Start | W, 41-21 | ||||||
| Whitmer | L, 19-27 | ||||||
| St. Francis | W, 45-0 | ||||||
| Central | W, 13-6 | ||||||
| State Playoffs | |||||||
| Canton McKinley | L, 21-28 | ||||||
| 2007 | 6-5 | ||||||
| Findlay | W, 40-27 | ||||||
| Columbus DeSales | L, 0-31 | ||||||
| Strongsville | W, 30-17 | ||||||
| Central | W, 15-7 | ||||||
| Rogers | L, 21-22 | ||||||
| Clay | W, 41-7 | ||||||
| Whitmer | L, 21-28 OT | ||||||
| Waite | W, 27-0 | ||||||
| Start | L, 23-28 | ||||||
| St. Francis | W, 37-7 | ||||||
| State Playoffs | |||||||
| North Canton Hoover | L, 33-40 5OT | ||||||